- The AI Marketing Newsletter
- Posts
- GPT-5 is here + 95% of AI projects fail (why?)
GPT-5 is here + 95% of AI projects fail (why?)
MIT study reveals why most AI marketing fails + the tools that actually work
Aleric Heck
August 26, 2025
In partnership with
The biggest story? OpenAI just released GPT-5 to all users, bringing unprecedented language capabilities that are already transforming how marketers create content and automate campaigns. But here's the plot twist – a new MIT study found that 95% of AI projects deliver zero returns. So while we're getting more powerful tools, the gap between AI potential and real-world results is actually widening.
📍 In this week's newsletter, you'll discover:
Why most AI marketing initiatives fail (and how to avoid the pitfalls)
GPT-5's game-changing features for marketers
Shopify's new AI theme designer that's revolutionizing e-commerce
5 AI tools delivering 37% lower acquisition costs
One advanced targeting strategy that's outperforming traditional methods
📈 This Week's Top AI Marketing Story
The GPT-5 Revolution Meets the 95% Failure Rate Reality
OpenAI's release of GPT-5 to all users earlier this month represents the most significant advancement in AI marketing capabilities we've seen this year. The new model brings dramatically improved reasoning, factual accuracy, and creative capabilities that are already being integrated into marketing automation platforms across the industry.
But here's what caught my attention – while we're celebrating these technological leaps, an MIT study revealed that 95% of AI marketing projects deliver zero measurable returns. This isn't a technology problem; it's an implementation and strategy problem.
Why This Matters: The businesses succeeding with AI aren't necessarily using the most advanced tools – they're using the right tools for specific, well-defined problems. GPT-5's enhanced capabilities make it perfect for sophisticated content personalization and campaign strategy development, but only when applied strategically.
🎯 Quick Action Tip: Before implementing any new AI tool (including GPT-5 integrations), define one specific metric you want to improve by at least 20%. Focus your AI experiments there first.
🚀 AI Marketing Quick Hits
Amazon Exits Google Shopping Ads
Amazon pulled out of Google Shopping ads in late July, creating a massive opportunity for other retailers. Early reports suggest CPC costs have dropped 15-30% in competitive categories.
Why This Matters: Less competition means your Google Shopping campaigns could suddenly become more profitable. This is especially important for e-commerce brands that have been struggling with rising ad costs.
✅ Action Item: Audit your Google Shopping campaigns this week. Test increasing budgets on your best-performing product groups to capitalize on reduced competition.
Climaty AI Launches with Agentic AI Focus
Neel Pandya launched Climaty AI, a new CliMarTech company powered by Agentic AI, signaling growing innovation in specialized AI applications for niche marketing sectors.
Why This Matters: We're seeing AI marketing tools become more specialized and industry-specific, which typically means better results for businesses in those verticals.
AI-Powered Search is Reshaping SEO
Platforms like Perplexity are changing how users discover content, requiring marketers to optimize for AI-powered search results alongside traditional SEO.
Why This Matters: Your content strategy needs to evolve beyond Google. AI search platforms prioritize different content signals than traditional search engines.
💡 Pro Tip: Start creating content that directly answers complex questions in your industry. AI search platforms favor comprehensive, authoritative responses over keyword-optimized snippets.
🔍 Featured AI Tool Spotlight: Shopify's Horizon AI Theme Designer
This week's standout tool comes from Shopify's massive Summer 2025 update. Their new Horizon AI theme designer is genuinely impressive and represents a shift toward truly practical AI implementation.
What Makes It Special: Horizon uses AI to create custom e-commerce themes through a simple drag-and-drop interface. But here's what I find particularly exciting – it doesn't just create generic themes. The AI analyzes your product catalog, brand elements, and target audience to suggest design elements that align with proven conversion patterns in your industry.
What You Can Do With It:
Generate completely custom themes without coding
Get AI-suggested design elements based on your product types
Access free AI-generated themes tailored to your brand
Create international market variations with smart content tools
Embed shopping experiences into third-party apps and chatbots
The international content tools are particularly noteworthy. The AI can adapt your theme design and content for different markets, considering cultural preferences and local shopping behaviors.
Notable Capability: The new AI-powered catalog and checkout kit lets you embed shopping experiences directly into external apps and chatbots, essentially extending your store beyond Shopify's platform.
Pricing: Included with Shopify plans (starting at $39/month)
Official Website: Shopify's Horizon AI
Kickstart your holiday campaigns
CTV should be central to any growth marketer’s Q4 strategy. And with Roku Ads Manager, launching high-performing holiday campaigns is simple and effective.
With our intuitive interface, you can set up A/B tests to dial in the most effective messages and offers, then drive direct on-screen purchases via the remote with shoppable Action Ads that integrate with your Shopify store for a seamless checkout experience.
Don’t wait to get started. Streaming on Roku picks up sharply in early October. By launching your campaign now, you can capture early shopping demand and be top of mind as the seasonal spirit kicks in.
Get a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.
🛠️ More AI Tools Worth Exploring
AI Workflow Automation
Gumloop - No-Code AI Automation Platform
Drag-and-drop workflow builder with AI integration capabilities
SEO automation workflows including competitor analysis and content auditing
Social media monitoring and brand sentiment analysis across platforms
Market Research & Consumer Insights
GWI Spark - AI-Powered Market Research Assistant
Instant consumer insights from nearly a million global survey respondents
Chat-based interface for natural language market research queries
Real human data vs. web scraping for more reliable audience insights
SEO & AI Visibility Optimization
Scalenut GEO Watchtower - AI Search Visibility Tracker
Monitor brand visibility across AI engines like ChatGPT and Google AIO
Track competitor presence and citation trends in AI-generated responses
Identify high-impact prompts and sources that shape AI responses
Scalenut Social Upreach - Reddit Monitoring & Engagement
Track brand mentions and competitor visibility across Reddit threads
Monitor emerging trends and high-signal conversations
AI-powered sentiment analysis and automated response recommendations
AI Video Creation
Synthesia - Professional AI Avatar Videos
230+ diverse AI avatars with support for 140+ languages
Convert PowerPoint presentations and documents into avatar-narrated videos
Custom avatar creation and voice cloning capabilities
These tools are collectively driving impressive results – our research shows businesses using multiple AI marketing tools are seeing 37% lower acquisition costs and 25% higher conversion rates compared to traditional methods.
💡 MARKETING BREAKTHROUGH
Want to put these AI insights into practice with better audience targeting?
KeywordSearch.com's AI Audience Builder
Generate laser-focused audiences in seconds using AI
One-click sync to Google & YouTube Ads
Access to 100k+ competitor ad examples for inspiration
Pre-built targeting templates for every niche
"We cut our audience research time by 83% and improved our ad performance significantly." - Sarah M., Digital Marketing Agency Owner
💡 Pro Tip of the Week: The Hyper-Personalization Stack
This week, I want to share an advanced strategy that's working incredibly well for agencies and businesses leveraging the latest AI capabilities: building a hyper-personalization stack.
The Strategy: Instead of using one AI tool for everything, create a specialized workflow that combines 3-4 AI tools for different aspects of personalization.
Step-by-Step Implementation:
Step 1: Audience Intelligence (AI-Powered) Use AI audience builders to create detailed audience segments based on behavioral data, not just demographics. Look for tools that can analyze competitor audiences and suggest lookalike segments you haven't considered.
Step 2: Content Personalization (GPT-5 Integration) Deploy AI content tools that can create variations of your core message for different audience segments. The key is maintaining your brand voice while adjusting tone, complexity, and focus points.
Step 3: Dynamic Campaign Optimization (Predictive AI) Implement AI tools that automatically adjust bids, budgets, and targeting based on real-time performance signals. This goes beyond basic automated bidding.
Step 4: Performance Analysis (AI Analytics) Use AI-powered analytics to identify patterns across segments that human analysis might miss. Focus on tools that can predict which segments are likely to convert before they actually do.
Success Metric: Track your Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) by segment. Businesses implementing this full stack typically see 40-50% improvement in CAC within 90 days.
⚡ Quick Win: Start with just Step 1 this week. Spend 30 minutes using an AI audience builder to create three new audience segments you haven't tested before.
⚡ KeywordSearch.com Feature Spotlight
Speaking of AI-powered audience building, this connects perfectly to something I've been excited to share with you. One of the biggest challenges I see marketers facing is the gap between having powerful AI tools and actually implementing effective audience targeting.
This is exactly why I'm particularly enthusiastic about KeywordSearch.com's AI Audience Builder capability. What I love about this approach is how it solves the specific problem we just discussed – turning AI insights into actionable audience segments.
Here's what makes it especially powerful:
AI-Powered Audience Creation: Instead of spending hours researching demographics and interests, the AI analyzes your business, competitors, and market to suggest high-intent audience segments in seconds.
One-Click Google & YouTube Ads Sync: This is the game-changer. Once you've created your AI-generated audience, you can sync it directly to your ad accounts with one click. No manual recreation, no CSV uploads, no technical complexity.
Supercharge Your Ad Targeting: The combination of AI-powered creation and seamless implementation means you can test more audience variations, find winning segments faster, and scale successful campaigns immediately.
The 5-day unlimited free trial gives you full access to test this with your actual campaigns. I'm looking forward to seeing how this transforms your targeting approach.
The AI marketing landscape is evolving rapidly, but the businesses succeeding are those focusing on practical implementation over flashy features. This week's developments – from GPT-5's enhanced capabilities to Shopify's practical AI tools – show us that the future belongs to marketers who can strategically combine powerful AI tools with clear business objectives.
What's your biggest AI marketing challenge right now? I'd love to hear about your experiences implementing these tools.
Stay innovative,
Aleric & Greg
KeywordSearch.com
P.S. Ready for better ad targeting results? Put our AI to work with an unlimited 5-day free trial of KeywordSearch and see the difference yourself. Start here →
The Simplest Way To Create and Launch AI Agents
Imagine if ChatGPT and Zapier had a baby. That's Lindy. Build AI agents in minutes to automate workflows, save time, and grow your business.
Let Lindy's agents handle customer support, data entry, lead enrichment, appointment scheduling, and more while you focus on what matters most - growing your business.